Greenleaf Trust is a comprehensive wealth management firm with specialized disciplines in goals-based wealth management, trust administration and retirement plan services.

Take-Away: A charitable gift annuity (CGA) is not the equivalent of a charitable remainder trust (CRT) for many different reasons.

Background: Recently I have volunteered my time with a nonprofit organization that is updating its gift acceptance policy. Part of the discussions have centered on whether the charity would offer charitable gift annuities (CGAs) to prospective donors. Someone on the committee remarked in those discussions that a CGA ‘is just like a charitable remainder trust.’ I politely took issue with that remark for a variety of reasons, not the least important being that a CGA is not formally recognized under the Tax Code, like a split-interest charitable remainder trust (CRT.) Some of the other distinctions between the two charitable giving strategies are summarized the end of this missive.

CGA Defined: A charitable gift annuity (CGA)  is practically speaking a bargain-sale by the donor to the charity, where cash or property is transferred to a charity in exchange for the charity’s unsecured promise to pay a fixed annuity either to the donor or to another individual for their life. The excess value of the property that the charity receives over the present value of the annuity that the donor receives is currently deductible by the donor as a charitable contribution. If appreciated property is the subject of the transfer to the charity, the income tax basis in the asset is allocated between the donor’s gift portion and the sale portion to determine the recognized gain that is spread over the annuitant’s lifetime.

Example 1: Donna, age 75, gifts $100,000 cash to her church in exchange for quarterly payments using a CGA. The IRC 7520 rate on the date of the gift is 4.6%. The American Council on Gift Annuities suggests that the maximum annuity rate for someone 75 years old is 7%. Accordingly, the annuity paid to Donna is $7,000 a year. Using the IRS mortality tables [IRC 72] Donna’s life expectancy is 12.4 years, such that the present value of Donna’s annuity is $60,737. Donna’s charitable deduction from her bargain-sale to her church will be $39,263 [$100,000- $60.737 = $39,263.] Part of Donna’s annuity will be tax-free. Donna’s life expectancy is multiplied by her $7,000 annual annuity amount to identify her expected return from the annuity, or $86,800. The amount of each annuity payment that is excluded from Donna’s income is the purchase price of her annuity ($60,737) divided by the expected return ($86,800) which is 70%. Therefore, 70% of each annuity payment that Donna receives is excluded from income, or $4,900 per year until there is a complete recovery of Donna’s income tax basis in 12.4 years. After all of Donna’s basis in the annuity is recovered, the entire annuity amount will then be taxable to her. If Donna dies prior to the passage of 12.4 years, any unrecovered basis is deductible on Donna’s final income tax return. [IRC 72(b)(3).]

Example 2: Same facts as the first Example, but Donna is married to Gus, also age 75, and they desire to obtain a two-life CGA from their church. The American Council’s maximum recommended annuity for a two-life CGA is 6.2%. This CGA would pay Donna and Gus $6,200 a year. Their joint life expectancy is 16.4 years. Using the same IRC 7520 rate, Donna and Gus’ charitable deduction will be $32,325, and the nontaxable amount of each annual annuity payment they receive will be $4,129 ($2,071 being taxable to Donna and Gus, or to the survivor of the two.)

Example 3: Same facts as Example 2, but in this case marketable securities are the subject of the transfer from Donna and Gus to their church, not cash. Donna and Gus transfer stock with a fair market value $100,000, but their stock has a cost basis of $50,000. In this case only $2,066 of each annual annuity payment would be nontaxable to Donna and Gus, and $2,063 would be taxed to them as capital gains. Consequently, the capital gain portion of each annuity payment received would reduce what would otherwise have been a nontaxable return of their investment in the CGA had cash been transferred to their church.

ACGA’s Suggested Rates: The American Council of Gift Annuities suggested maximum annuity rate, which most charities follow, is intended, as a generalization, to spread the actuarial risk, leading to a residuum of 20% to the charity. However, as another generalization, the amount remaining for the charity after the annuitant’s death, often is about 50% of the donor’s original contribution amount. Moreover, in studies that the ACGA has conducted over the past three decades a rough calculation is that the amount received by the charity under a CGA on the annuitant’s death is closer to 75%. The assumptions on which the ACGA rate assumption is based include: (i) 45%-55% male/female mortality blend; (ii) 1% annual investment and administrative expense; (iii) annual expected investment return of 5.75%; and (iv) quarterly payments to the annuitant.

IRC 7520: There is some flexibility in the IRC 7520 rate that is used to value the CGA. The donor can elect either the IRC 7520 rate for the month of the transfer of property to the charity or either of the prior two months. The higher the interest rate, the higher the charitable deduction. A lower interest rate will exclude more of each annuity payment from income as part of the nontaxable return of basis in the annuity contract.

[Aside: When looking at interest rates, if a split-interest CRAT is used, a higher interest rate is always better. With a split-interest CRUT, a higher interest rate is always better, but with minimal impact on the deduction. A gift of a remainder interest in a residence to charity will be better when interest rates are lower. If a split-interest CLAT is used, a lower interest rate is always better.]

Be Wary of…: The focus on generating a higher charitable income tax deduction with a CGA is a non-starter if the donor does not itemize his/her income taxes. Ask. Moreover, a CGA that is purchased with appreciated property for another individual (i.e., the annuitant) will trigger gain recognition that is immediately recognized and taxed to the CGA purchaser, rather than the gain being spread over the annuitant’s life expectancy. Finally, some CGA purchasers at a late date decide that they no longer need the annuity payments, and they decide to assign their residual interest in the CGA to the charity. As noted earlier, if the annuitant assigns his/her remaining CGA interest to the charity before their basis has not been fully recovered, he/she is limited in their charitable deduction to their unrecovered basis in the contract. If the annuitant has lived past his/her life expectancy, he/she can claim no deduction for this ‘last gift.’

Comparing CGAs with CRTs: Often the biggest distinction mentioned when comparing a CGA with a charitable remainder trust (CRT) is that the smaller amount (or value) that will be the subject of a gratuitous transfer, the more likely a CGA is warranted due to the small expense associated with setting up the CGA. The larger the amount (or value) of the planned transfer will justify the additional cost to set up a CRT, file the annual tax return, and pay administrative expense to maintain the CRT. A charity might accept a CGA for a contribution (gift) as low as $5,000 to $10,000. A CRT is probably not economical if the trust will receive less than $250,000.  There are other differences between a CGA and CRT that need to be considered as well as the amount of the gift.

Self-Dealing Rules: CRT’s are subject to most of the self-dealing limitations that are imposed on private foundations. Those same self-dealing limitations (and penalties)  do not apply to a CGA.

Example: Don owns an office building. Don would like to contribute the building to a charity, but Don would like to continue use his small office space in the building after his gift of the building to charity. Don is prepared to pay fair rental value for the office space. Don could not rent the office space from a CRT that holds title to the building as that would be a form of prohibited self-dealing. In contrast, if Don gives the building to a charity in exchange for a CGA, Don can lease space in the building because the private foundation self-dealing rules do not apply to CGAs.

Annuity Rate: As noted above, most charities that deal with CGAs will follow the ACGA recommended maximum annuity rate. With a CRT the donor sets the annuity rate, but that decision is limited by the Tax Code’s 5% exhaustion limitation and 10% (minimum value of charitable remainder interest) conditions (more on those below.) [IRC 664.]

Deferral: A CGA contribution can defer the annuity starting date. A CRT cannot defer the start of distributions to the CRT’s beneficiary. The longer the annuity is deferred, the larger the annuity payout will eventually be.

Future Increases: A CGA can increase its annuity amount each year. With a CRAT, the annuity amount must be fixed  ‘up front.’ A CGA’s step-annuity, which increases annually according to a fixed schedule can keep a pace with inflation unlike a CRAT. The step-annuity can also be coupled with a CGA deferral provision.

Appreciated Tangible Personal Property: A CGA can be funded with appreciated tangible personal property. If the charity is able to use that personal property in a manner that is related to its tax exempt purposes, the charitable deduction to the donor will be based on the asset’s fair market value rather than on its basis. With a CRT, because the ‘trust’ cannot use the property in a way that is related to its tax exempt purpose, the charitable deduction will be limited to the asset’s income tax basis.

Example: Donna donates valuable artwork to a museum in exchange for a CGA. Since the museum displays artwork as part of its tax exempt purpose, the fair market value of the artwork is deductible by Donna. If the artwork were contributed by Donna to a CRT, only the tax basis in the artwork could be deducted by her.

Control of Investments: The annuitant under the CGA cannot control investments. With a CRT, the donor-trustee-beneficiary can control the CRT’s investments.

Change of Beneficiary: With a CGA the charitable beneficiary cannot be changed. With a CRT, the donor can reserve the right to change the CRT’s charitable remainder beneficiary.

Tax- Free Income: With the CGA, a part of each distribution can be an income tax-free return of basis. With a CRT, the income is taxed under the IRS’s sophisticated tiered system, which might be entirely taxed to the donor.

5% and 10% Exhaustion Rules: The Tax Code uses a 5% exhaustion rule for CRT’s, which can make a CRAT impossible to use in a low interest rate environment. [Revenue Ruling 77-374.]  In contrast, there is no 5% exhaustion rule applied to CGAs.

Example: Donna, age 70, wants to contribute $100,000 of Apple stock to her church in exchange for a fixed quarterly annuity at the ACGA recommended annuity rate of 6.3%. The prevailing IRC 7520 rate is 4.4%. If a CRAT is funded by Donna, the CRT’s charitable remainder will be valued at $33,642, and the CRAT will pass the IRS’s minimum 10% remainder value ‘test,’ but the CRT will fail the IRS’s 5% exhaustion ‘test’ because the probability of the charity’s remainder interest’s exhaustion is 6.694%, and the CRT would not qualify for the tax deduction by Donna. If a CGA had been used by Donna, there would be either no 5% or 10% ‘test’ to pass to obtain a tax deduction.

Run Out of Funds: A CGA cannot run out of money so long as the charity is solvent. In contrast, a CRT can run out of funds if the trust is exhausted due to under-investment performance.

Duration: A CGA must be for one or two lives only. With a CRT it can be for a term of years, or more than two lives, or shorter of life or lives and a term of years.

Charitable Deduction: A CGA affords a charitable deduction for the gift of the remaining income interest that is limited to unrecovered basis, which may be $0.00. With a CRT, the charitable deduction is for the actuarial value of the remaining income interest.

S Corporate Stock: With a CGA, the charity can hold S corporate stock, although income will be taxable, including on the sale of the S stock by the charity. With a CRT a CRAT is not able to be an S corporation shareholder.

Still Unknown: One last point is some continued uncertainty with regard to the marital deduction with a joint CGA. If the CGA is for the donor’s life, and then for the donor’s spouse for life, it is not clear if the marital deduction is available for the spouse’s survivorship interest because of IRC 2523(f)(6) provides for a marital deduction only in a joint and survivor annuity. In the latter situation, the donee spouse’s interest is treated as a qualifying income interest for life and the donor spouse is treated as having made a QTIP election unless the donor spouse ‘opts out’ of the election. With the ‘continuing life annuity for the donor’s spouse, the answer is less clear. Therefore, if the spouse is to have a successor interest, but not a joint interest, in the annuity, the CGA should be structured so that the donor spouse retains the right to revoke his/her surviving spouse’s survivor interest so there is no completed gift by the donor spouse until the donor’s death.

Conclusion: A charitable gift annuity works something like a charitable remainder trust, but with its own benefits and drawbacks. A CGA may be preferable to a CRT from an income tax perspective because of the tax-free portion of each payment, which is generally not the case with a CRT which is taxed following the tiered income tax rules of IRC 664. If most donors no longer itemize their income taxes or only bunch their charitable deductions into years to avoid the limitation on deductions under IRC 68, they may want to opt to use a CGA just to simplify their philanthropy .

 

If you would like to read additional missives, click here.

 

View PDF

Contact Us